The 2025/26 season unfolds within a volatile macroeconomic and trade environment. Global oversupply, currency fluctuations, and shifting regional trade policies are reshaping the competitive landscape for sugar producers worldwide. For South Africa, these dynamics are translating into tangible pressures at home, most notably through increased imports and subdued domestic sugar demand. As these trends converge mid-season, they signal that the remainder of the year may bring continued challenges for the local industry, if remain unabated.

Macroeconomic Outlook and Exchange rate Risks

South Africa’s growth trajectory remains modest. The OECD projects GDP growth of 1.3% in 2025 and 1.4% in 2026. Meanwhile, Investec’s recent forecast is more cautious, estimating 0.9% growth for 2025. Inflation expectations are manageable, with consensus pointing to easing pressures supported by a somewhat stronger Rand. In the first quarter, real GDP growth was marginal (+0.1%) as domestic demand remained constrained.

From a monetary policy perspective, the SARB has room for gradual easing. The May 2025 Monetary Policy Committee statement implied rate cuts contingent on inflation trajectories. Interest rate relief may help consumption and industrial activity, but persistent structural constraints (energy, logistics, investor confidence) will likely mute impact.

Exchange rate dynamics are central to the sugar trade. As of early October 2025, the USD/ZAR rate was around R17.22, after recent Rand appreciation. But volatility remains high, any sustained strengthening would erode producers’ ability to compete with imports. Conversely, Rand weakness would amplify local margins but push up input costs. Modeling estimates of exchange-rate pass-through to inflation range around 15 to 20%, indicating that significant currency moves will affect domestic pricing power.

In this context, our “base-case exchange rate” assumption (near current levels) underpins exposure risk estimates, yet downside scenarios where the Rand strengthens unexpectedly, are material.

Global Sugar Market Outlook: Oversupply and Price Pressure

In global sugar prices, fundamentals lean bearish. The USDA’s May 2025 outlook raised global production by 4.7% year-on-year, to a record 189.32 million metric tons (MMT), while consumption is estimated to increase only 1.4%. The result: a projected global surplus and rising stocks, with ending stocks estimated to climb 7.5% y/y to 41.19 MMT. Analyst consensus and scenario forecasts suggest that global sugar prices will remain under downward pressure over the next six to twelve months, absent a major weather shock or policy reversal such as export restrictions. The OECD-FAO outlook similarly flags mild price decline over the medium term, subject to uncertainty in commodity cycles and climate shifts.

For South Africa, this global softness presents a downside risk, as lower world prices make imports more attractive and exert competitive pressure on local producers, reinforcing the challenges faced by domestic stakeholders in an already fragile market. In sum, South African producers are facing a global environment where oversupply constrains upside and importers are incentivized to arbitrage across regions.

The Import Challenge: A Central Threat

Behind the domestic contraction lies an escalating import challenge. Imports from Eswatini rose by 24% year-on-year by July 2025. This steady inflow of import sugar reflects both historical trade dynamics and price competitiveness from regional producers.

Evidently, it was the June to July spike in deep-sea imports that significantly disrupted the market. Driven by a combination of factors, not least of which was the delay in gazetting the import duty which came to effect only on 1 August 2025 at R3,647 per ton; this regulatory gap amplified existing incentives for importers of cheaper sugar. Imports in July 2025 alone reached over 34 000 tons, underscoring the extent to which even short-term policy lags can expose the local market to opportunistic inflows.

The economics of these imports remain concerning. During the winter months, the gap between global import parity levels and the local notional price widened considerably, creating favourable conditions for opportunistic inflows. This dynamic was further reinforced by relative Rand stability, which, while beneficial for inflation, increased the attractiveness of imported sugar for traders and industrial users. Under prevailing exchange rates and market conditions, local producers faced a meaningful exposure risk, as imported product landed at prices significantly more competitive than domestic benchmarks. The margin was sufficient to displace local volumes in certain regions and segments, despite efforts to contain the impact.

Regionally, the Western Cape and the Eastern Cape remain highly vulnerable due to logistical proximity to ports. This risk has prompted the roll-out of short-term regional intervention for industrial clients in these provinces, effective 1 September 2025 as a tactical defence against further market erosion.

Domestic Market Signals: Broad-Based Demand Weakness

Domestic market performance in the first half of the 2025/26 season has fallen short of expectations, with broad-based weakness observed across both industrial and direct consumption segments. Notably, several historically stable categories have softened, and industrial applications have borne the brunt of the pressure. Geographically, most provinces have seen lower year-on-year demand, reflecting a national trend of subdued consumption. The overall trajectory points to a softer-than-anticipated season, warranting close monitoring in the months ahead.

Regional Trade and Protectionist Postures

Regionally, sugar producers across Africa and Asia continue to defend their domestic markets. In South Africa’s case, Eswatini remains a major source of intra-regional supply, up approximately 24% year-on-year by mid-season, with stable volumes averaging approx. 29,000 tons monthly.

SADC-origin imports, while still modest, rose to 666 tons from just 50 tons in the prior season. This is indicative of shifting regional trade patterns under global surplus dynamics.

Across sub-Saharan Africa, economic conditions are relatively resilient. The African Development Bank projects regional growth of 3.9% in 2025, potentially supporting incremental demand. However, competing sugar-exporting nations are clearly focused on safeguarding their own markets via tariff measures, quotas, and regional agreements, heightening competitive pressures in cross-border corridors.

In this ecology, South Africa’s pricing, rebate systems, and duty framework will need nimble calibration to maintain competitiveness without undermining broader trade commitments.

What to Expect for the Remainder of the Season

Given the macro, trade, and global sugar dynamics, below are some plausible trajectories and risks for the remainder of 2025:

• Global sugar prices are likely to remain under pressure, with slight declines or stagnation unless disrupted by extreme weather or abrupt export policy shifts.

• Exchange rate scenario: If the Rand strengthens to the low-R16s, importers gain advantage and domestic margins are squeezed. If the Rand weakens, local producers regain buffer, but input inflation could offset gains.

• Domestic resilience: Industrial demand may recover marginally if monetary easing stimulates activity. But any rebound will be modest given structural constraints such as logistics bottlenecks, underinvestment in infrastructure, and investor caution; even if load-shedding risks have abated for now.

Conclusion: A Resilient Industry at an Inflection Point

This mid-season juncture reveals that the domestic sugar industry is not only fighting local headwinds but is operating within a global tide of surplus and low-price momentum. The macroeconomic outlook, especially the trajectory of the Rand and interest rates, will strongly mediate how well local producers hold ground.

While the block exemption has been gazetted, phase 2 of the broader sugar value chain master plan is yet to be formally launched. In this evolving environment, the industry’s best leverage will be through continuous, data-driven collaboration with government, trade agencies, and downstream users. Monitoring trade flows in real time, scenario planning for currency movements and other market contingencies, and preparing rapid-response buffer measures will be crucial in the months ahead.

Above all, foresight will matter more than reaction: to safeguard market share in an over-supplied world, the industry must anticipate shifts, not simply respond to them.

Andile Sibanda is an Economist at SASA

SUGAR AND MPUMALANGA GOVERNMENT

Sugar industry and mpumalanga government join forces

The sugar industry and Mpumalanga Premier Mandla Ndlovu have committed to working together to ensure t...

SASA Regional Projects

Sasa regional projects – transformation intervention driving inclusive growth across the sugar industry

As part of the extended Transformation Plan, the South African Sugar Industry has continued to make me...